A website that provides a detailed explanation of the confusing reality of eco-cutes
A website that provides a detailed explanation of the confusing reality of eco-cutes
There are mixed opinions about EcoCute, but if you actually search online, you will find that electricity industry pages say that hot water costs will be 1500 yen per month (8000 yen per year), while gas industry pages even say that it will cost nearly 5 yen per year.
While I was re-examining the situation on my own, I found an amazing website.
EcoCute power consumption and electricity bills: How often does it run out of hot water?
It has been 14 years since EcoCute was released, but I have never seen such a detailed explanation. There were many things I did not know myself, so I decided to ask a layperson to explain. Incidentally, the author of this page is an extremely intelligent person who built his house with Ichijo Komuten while working at a certain research institute. I think it is an important fact that such an intelligent person would choose Ichijo Komuten.
The first thing I looked into was the national standards.
According to the data, the annual primary energy consumption in Tokyo is
EcoJozu 18.6GJ
4GJ when used in conjunction with a 11.8mXNUMX solar hot water heater
Ecocute is 16.7GJ
Has become.
Looking at this, EcoCute doesn't seem so bad after all.
Let's start with some simple gas calculations.
18.6GJ=18600MJ=5167kWh
Gas is 12.8kW/m170 and the cost per cubic meter is approximately XNUMX yen.
(5167/12.8) x 170 = 68624 yen (1 year)
.
A similar calculation was performed for a solar hot water heater.
The gas bill savings from using a solar water heater will be 25088 yen (per year).
The resulting gas bill will be 43536 yen.
If we assume that the additional cost of a solar water heater is 25 yen, the payback period will be exactly 10 years.
The above is a calculation based on government documents, but the calculation is probably based on a flat panel solar water heater.
I also performed calculations using a vacuum tube type solar water heater, which is effective during cold seasons.
If 3 m3 of vacuum tube system is installed, 223 m3 of city gas can be saved per year.
This translates into a savings of 37910 yen.
As a result, the gas bill will be 30714 yen, and assuming the additional cost is 25 yen, the payback period will be 6.6 years.
This turned out to be a much better result.
Next is EcoCute.
The first calculation is the same as for gas.
16.7GJ=16700MJ=4639kWh (primary energy)
This is the energy used in power plants.
It needs to be converted into energy for use at home.
4639/2.7=1718kWh
You might think that eco-cutes would normally only operate during late-night electricity hours, but if you look closely at the contents of the website I introduced first, you will see that 92% of them operate on late-night electricity, and XNUMX% at other times.
If we calculate the unit prices for Kansai Electric Power, the price for late-night electricity is 11.07 yen/kWh, and for other times it is 28.9 yen/kWh.
When we calculate these proportionately, the annual electricity bill for an eco-cute, calculated from government data, comes to 19217 yen.
We have customers who use both EcoCute and EcoJozu. Their impression is that "EcoCute was definitely cheaper until now."
However, this has only been the case up until now, and the honest truth is that no one knows what will be the cheapest in the future, depending on the state of nuclear power, electricity liberalization, and shale gas imports.
The author of this website himself states that he is "a person who uses a lot of hot water." In this case, the electricity bill for the EcoCute is 35000 yen. Although this is 84% higher than the national estimate, the biggest thing I learned from this experience is that it is still lower than the average gas bill for EcoJozu.
However, no conclusions can be drawn from this study as to whether this system will compete in combination with vacuum tube solar hot water heaters.
It is important to note that this is an area with temperatures similar to that of Tokyo.
The colder the climate, the more of a disadvantage the Ecocute becomes. I don't know at what point the situation will turn around.















